What to Expect if you Receive an Accessibility Complaint
For the purposes of this document, we’re going to focus on the legal accessibility requirements for a typical commercial website which is not affiliated with or selling products or services to any government agency. That will mean that you must adhere to ADA Title III & State Civil Rights Laws, meeting the standards of WCAG 2.1 / 2.2 Level AA - this is the de facto standard applied by both the courts and the Department of Justice (DOJ). You can review those standards at https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/.
From a User
Suppose you get an email from a user who complains that they were frustrated with their interaction with your website. They say their screen-reader was unable to guide them through your site and the keyboard navigation didn’t work as it should. What should you do?
· Reply promptly. Your first step should be a warm, appreciative response as soon as possible – preferably within one business day - thanking them for bringing the issue to your attention.
· Provide an immediate workaround. Offer a direct phone number, email address, or live chat option so a team member can help them complete their task right away.
· Keep language neutral. Avoid admitting that your site violates the ADA or WCAG, and simply state that you are committed to making your site usable for everyone. Simply state that you will immediately begin investigating the issue on your end, and if you find any deficiencies, you will immediately take corrective action.
· Ask clarifying questions if needed. Ask the user to share information regarding which device, browser, or assistive technology (like a screen reader) they were using, and what page(s) they were on when they experienced the issue - or any further amplifying information they can offer, - that may help your technicians identify where the problem exists.
· Promise a further response. Tell them you will be getting back to them promptly with the findings of your investigation, telling them what issues you found, if any, and what corrective action you are taking to ensure the problem is resolved. Give them a time-frame within which you’ll be getting back to them and be certain to do so, even if only to tell them you are still working on the issue and provide a new time-frame. If your investigation detects any failures to comply, do NOT point them out as such – simply state that a certain functionality seems questionable, and that you are continuing your investigation and corrective actions.
At every single step, document all communication, investigations, findings, and actions taken. If further legal actions ensue, this documentation will be critical.
From a Law Firm
What if the user contacted an attorney and that attorney sends a demand letter, seeking specific corrective actions and a sum of money for their plaintiff (and themselves, of course)?
When a user hires a private attorney and sends a demand letter to a commercial business, the process shifts completely from federal agency oversight to private civil dispute resolution. Unlike a DOJ inquiry, which focuses on public enforcement and systemic compliance, a private demand letter is a pre-litigation tactic designed to secure a financial settlement and a binding agreement before a formal lawsuit is filed in court.
Here is how the communication and process typically unfold when a business receives a private ADA demand letter:
1. The Initial Demand Letter
The communication arrives via certified mail or email directly from a plaintiff’s law firm—often one that specializes in high-volume ADA Title III litigation.
- The Allegations: The letter identifies the plaintiff (such as an individual who is blind or visually impaired using screen-reading software) and lists specific dates they attempted to use the website. It includes a summary of technical barriers found, such as missing alt text, broken keyboard navigation, or unlabeled form fields.
- The Demands: The letter typically demands three things:
- Website Remediation: Bringing the site into compliance with WCAG 2.1 or 2.2 Level AA within a set timeframe (often 6 to 12 months).
- Monetary Payment: A lump sum to cover the plaintiff’s attorneys' fees and statutory damages (note: while federal ADA Title III does not award monetary damages to private plaintiffs, attorneys frequently bundle state civil rights laws—like California's Unruh Act or New York's Human Rights Law—which do allow statutory damages, starting at $4,000+ per violation).
- A Deadline to Respond: The letter usually gives a strict window for receiving a response — often 10 to 21 days — before the attorney threatens to file a formal complaint in federal or state court.
2. Legal Representation and the "Litigation Hold"
Once the business receives the letter, direct communication between the business owner and the plaintiff's attorney should stop immediately. IMPORTANT!
- Retaining ADA Counsel: The business hires an attorney experienced in ADA defense. Your attorney will send a brief Letter of Representation to the plaintiff's lawyer, stating that all future communication must go through defense counsel and requesting a short extension (usually 14 to 30 days) to investigate the claims.
- Internal Audit (Under Privilege): Your attorney will typically hire an independent web accessibility consultant to audit the website under attorney-client privilege. This keeps the audit results confidential while showing you what actually needs to be fixed.
3. Negotiation and Counteroffers
Communication then moves into back-and-forth negotiation between the two legal teams via email and phone calls.
- Challenging Standing and Jurisdiction: Defense counsel may push back if the plaintiff lives in another state and has no genuine intent to buy from a local business, or if the cited issues are minor or already fixed.
- Negotiating the Payout: Initial demand numbers are often inflated. Defense counsel will negotiate the financial figure down based on the size of the business, the cost of fixing the site, and whether the plaintiff has filed dozens of similar lawsuits (serial litigation).
- Remediation Timeline: Both sides agree on realistic deadlines for fixing the website, rather than unachievable 30-day demands.
4. The Confidential Settlement Agreement
If both sides agree on terms, the plaintiff's attorney drafts a Confidential Settlement Agreement and Release, which goes through a few rounds of redlines between the lawyers.
- Release of Claims: In exchange for the agreed-upon payment and promise to fix the site, the plaintiff legally waives their right to sue the business over the website's accessibility. (Note: This only protects you from that specific plaintiff—it does not stop a different plaintiff from filing a new claim later if the site remains broken).
- Confidentiality Clause: Unlike DOJ settlements, which are public record, private demand letter settlements almost always include strict non-disclosure clauses prohibiting either side from discussing the payout.
5. Post-Settlement Communication (or Escalation)
- If Settled: Once the check clears and the agreement is signed, communication usually ends entirely. Unlike the DOJ, private attorneys rarely conduct ongoing monitoring unless a follow-up check was specifically written into the agreement.
- If Ignored or Negotiations Fail: If the business ignores the demand letter or refuses to settle, the plaintiff's attorney will file a formal Summons and Complaint in court. Communication then shifts to formal federal or state court litigation procedures, which significantly increases legal defense costs.
We’ve all heard the term “ambulance-chaser”. It’s not terribly flattering to lawyers, but unfortunately, it does represent the practices of some lawyers’, as they tend to focus on opportunities to make money from the misfortune of others. This area of law is no different, as some firms employ an army of bots to search for websites with accessibility issues. Some even have a cadre of potential plaintiffs in whose name they can issue demand letters. Just because a firm does this, however, doesn’t mean their claims won’t be seen as having merit in a court of law. On the contrary, if their practice focuses heavily in the realm of accessibility, you should probably assume they (or their consulting auditors) know what they’re doing.
Obviously, retaining an attorney and auditor can present the website owner with unforeseen expenses – and those costs can escalate dramatically if the case ends up going to court. So the decision of whether to simply pay the demand letter or to fight it usually becomes a question of taking the less costly path.
From the Department of Justice
But what if a user complained to an agency and the complaint was forwarded to the DOJ?
For a commercial business website, website accessibility falls under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which applies to "places of public accommodation."
Because the DOJ receives thousands of complaints each year and has limited enforcement bandwidth, the process for a commercial business differs somewhat from that of a government agency. Here is what typically happens if a complaint reaches the DOJ:
1. The Triage and Referral Phase
When someone files a Title III complaint against a commercial business, the DOJ rarely opens a full-scale federal investigation immediately unless the business is a major national brand, part of an industry-wide sweep, or the issue affects a large number of people. Instead, the DOJ usually takes one of three initial actions:
· No Action / File Closed: If the complaint lacks detail or falls outside their current enforcement priorities, the DOJ may simply log the complaint and take no direct action. In this case, the business owner receives no communication at all.
· Referral to the ADA Mediation Program: Rather than launching a formal investigation, the DOJ frequently sends a letter offering free, voluntary mediation through a DOJ-sponsored mediator. Both the business and the person who filed the complaint must agree to participate. This is confidential and avoids formal legal findings.
· Referral to a U.S. Attorney's Office: The Civil Rights Division may pass the complaint to the local U.S. Attorney's Office in the district where the business is located, which then decides whether to pursue legal action or to even contact the business.
2. Formal Investigation Communication (if pursued)
If the DOJ or a U.S. Attorney's Office decides to actively investigate a commercial business, the communication follows a formal legal track:
· Notice of Investigation / Letter of Inquiry: The business receives an official letter via certified mail or email from a DOJ trial attorney or Assistant U.S. Attorney. It states that a complaint has been filed alleging Title III violations regarding the website and outlines the specific barriers reported (e.g., incompatibility with screen readers, missing alt text, or inaccessible checkout flows).
· Document and Information Requests: The letter will include a formal request for information, typically giving the business 30 days to respond. They will ask for:
o Copies of any internal web accessibility policies or statements.
o Details about who designed, maintains, and hosts the website.
o Records of any accessibility audits, user testing, or remediation work already underway.
o Information on alternative ways customers with disabilities can access the business's goods or services (such as a 24/7 accessible customer service phone line).
· Attorney-to-Attorney Dialogue: Once the business retains legal counsel, the DOJ (or U.S. Attorney) communicates almost exclusively with the business's lawyers rather than the owner directly.
3. Resolution and Ongoing Reporting
If the DOJ confirms that the website violates Title III, the communication shifts toward negotiation rather than an immediate fine:
· Letter of Findings: In formal investigations, the DOJ issues a written determination detailing where the website falls short of accessibility standards (typically referencing WCAG 2.1 Level AA as the benchmark).
· Settlement Agreement Negotiations: The DOJ will draft and send a proposed Settlement Agreement. Unlike private lawsuits—which often demand quick cash payouts—the DOJ focuses heavily on systemic fixes. For a first-time commercial offense, the DOJ often prioritizes compliance over civil penalties, though monetary damages for the complainant or civil fines can still be negotiated.
· Post-Settlement Check-ins: Once signed, communication continues for the duration of the agreement (usually 1 to 3 years). The business must periodically send the DOJ written compliance reports, proof of staff training, and results from independent accessibility audits until the DOJ officially closes the file.
(Note: In the commercial world, actual DOJ investigations are relatively rare compared to private litigation. Most commercial business owners never hear from the DOJ; instead, they receive a demand letter or federal lawsuit directly from a private plaintiff's attorney alleging ADA Title III violations.)
Bear in mind, regarding your communications, actions, and documentation, the courts are still exhibiting a certain amount of appreciation of good-faith efforts to comply. So even if you don’t have the means of accomplishing everything today, making an honest effort to achieve some meaningful progress may help you. The sooner you start that process, the better.



